I just finished a pre-K teacher’s article about lockdown
drills (“Rehearsing for Death,” Launa Hall, https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/rehearsing-for-death-a-pre-k-teacher-on-the-trouble-with-lockdown-drills/2014/10/28/4ab456ea-5eb2-11e4-9f3a-7e28799e0549_story.html).
She wrote on choosing her words carefully to communicate the import yet not
terrify her tiny students, students we hope still retain a shred of innocence.
Hall focuses on her diction when talking to her students, using “activity” and
not “game” to convey a more serious tone. Not saying “police” because “some
little kids find police officers scary, and I can’t risk introducing tears.”
She also doesn’t use “quiet” for fear students will “shush” each other. She
doesn’t need quiet for these drills; she needs silence: “As silent as children
who aren’t there at all.” She then recounts an atypical lockdown drill. She
discusses the importance of body language and following protocol. She paints a
vivid picture of cramming “16 tiny bodies” and two adults into a closet. She
ends with a powerful couple paragraphs about lockdown drills focusing on the
wrong issue: “It’s time to stop rehearsing our deaths and start screaming”
about gun control.
Of course as I read the article, I vividly imagined the tiny
babies crammed into a closet and silently awaiting a potential shooter, but as
a teacher of 11+ years, I also thought of my own large babies—and how my
classes run 20-32 students.
I have taught 8th-12th grade and participated
in many, many drills: tornado, fire, lockdown. I have learned protocols and
code words for three different schools. I have learned to walk into my
classroom each year (and I’ve have many different rooms) and immediately
mentally assess furniture placement and how that will affect my students during
drills—and where I can pack their bodies.
For fire drills, we simply try to file out the nearest door
and congregate in one place so I can insure they all make it out. In two of my
schools, I was almost always the last one out so I could sweep the bathrooms
and watch for stragglers.
And, I silently and selfishly pray I’ll never actually have
to be the last one out in a real fire. I think of my own family dependent on
me. I also think of the new limitations lupus has placed on my physical
abilities.
For tornado drills, I watch my large athletes sitting with
their backs to me as they ludicrously try to make themselves too small for a
tornado to swallow them whole. I make eye contact with my fellow teachers as we
stand and pace the halls to ensure our students have assumed the position. We
also try to maintain order and quiet in the midst of teens who are weary of the
drills, who are bored of the routine, and who make jokes to hide the fact they
know tornados are a reality in our state. As I look at my comrades in arms, we
all silently acknowledge our standing and pacing puts us at the most risk—we
also know our hallways are not truly safe. I personally know my 5’5”, 119 lb
frame would never be able to shield all my children. Most of them outweigh me
and are taller than I. Sure, I can separate them when they fight (many times
just by raising my voice), but how do I save them from a force of nature?
And again, I silently and selfishly pray I’ll never actually
have to throw myself over them in a tornado. I think of my own family and my
physical limitations. I recognize my mental toughness but my physical weakness.
For lockdown drills, the reality is even more sobering. I have
had at least three rooms with an entire wall of external windows (one the 1st
floor; one on the second, with a building of equal height within shooting
distance and facing my room; one on the 3rd floor). I have had to
coldly calculate how many students could fit under and behind my desk and how
many could fit behind a barricade of student desks. I have had to look at my
students and logically plan how to pack them into a corner for maximum
protection. I have had to ruthlessly threaten them for making noise and not
taking this seriously. I know teens tend to have an invincibility complex, but
I have read books (fiction and nonfiction) about shootings. I know way too many
real-life examples. The names of towns and schools run through my mind as I
coldly tell my students to stay down and stay quiet. I’m good in crises (so
far), but I also shut down emotion. I cannot spare feelings when I have to
ponder if I would actually throw myself in front of my students and face down a
shooter. Would I really die for these children? I do love them, but what about
my own family? What about my own life?
Finally, I silently and selfishly pray I’ll never actually
have to stare down the barrel of a gun and choose between my life and my
students’. I remember my family and my physical limitations. I feel gutless and
cowardly for not delusionally and perkily stating I would lay down my body and
life for my students. I’m too much a calculated realist.
I love teaching; I’ve said that many times. But, while I
figuratively kill myself making sure my students are prepared for their
futures, making sure they leave my class with more knowledge and maybe more
wisdom and empathy, I don’t think I should have to entertain the scenario of
laying down my life for them. Why should I have to weigh the value of their
lives over my own child’s—and my life? I don’t want to be a hero. I simply want
to teach.
Honestly, I have no idea how I would react in any of these
situations. I am only human, and too many factors keep me from knowing I’d be a hero. I am only
a teacher, which is everything and nothing.
While I certainly appreciate and admire the 'hero stories' of teachers or anyone else who offer their lives or safety for another, I've never felt such efforts particularly tied to teaching. People do heroic things every day in all sorts of situations - and horrible things, and decent things, and selfish things, and just normal things.
ReplyDeleteI certainly plan on saving the day should anything evil unfold on my watch, but you're absolutely correct that none of us really know until it happens how we'll react.
No guilt for being honest about it up front.
I appreciate that. I'm too pragmatic to not realize my strengths and weaknesses. I guess I'm incapable of being a hero because I think too much.
DeleteHowever, I can hold a student's hair while he/she throws up. I can push students to finish work. I can help them improve as readers and writers. I can discuss the "hard" topics. Sometimes that is heroic.